Old Star, a photograph by ClaraXenia, framed in black and hanging in an interior

What an Image Can Set in Motion

Posted by ClaraXenia on

This article looks at the power of images and symbols: what a single picture, seen fully or only half seen, can set in motion in a person and sometimes in a whole society, and what that asks of anyone who makes images and shares them. It follows a hospital window, a photograph of the Earth, a pair of eyes above an honesty box and a famous claim about hidden messages, and it ends with the care we try to bring to our own images. In Seeing Comes Before Words we looked at how quickly and deeply we take pictures in. This piece follows what happens next.

In short · 6 min read

  • A view of trees helped surgery patients go home sooner (Ulrich, 1984).
  • One photograph, Earthrise, changed how millions pictured the planet.
  • Hidden images seem to nudge what is already there, rather than create new wants.
  • Images ask for care from the people who make them, and this is how we try to give it.

Wall Art: Photo Art and Words, framed

A window onto trees

Between 1972 and 1981, at a hospital in Pennsylvania, the researcher Roger Ulrich studied the records of patients recovering from gallbladder surgery. Some rooms looked out on a small stand of trees. Others faced a brown brick wall. He matched patients in pairs, alike in age, sex and other factors that could affect recovery, and compared how each pair did. The result, published in Science in 1984, was modest and striking. The patients with the view of trees went home sooner, needed fewer doses of strong painkillers and drew more positive notes from the nurses.

It was one hospital and twenty three pairs of patients, and Ulrich was careful about what it could show. It has still become one of the most quoted studies in hospital design, because it put numbers to something people had long sensed about the view from a bed. Many hospitals built since have been planned with windows, gardens and art on the walls, partly because of it.

Images do their work quietly, and they tend to strengthen what is already present in the person looking.

A photograph of the whole Earth

On 24 December 1968 the crew of Apollo 8 came round from the far side of the Moon and saw the Earth rising over its horizon. The astronaut Bill Anders took the photograph now known as Earthrise: a blue and white planet, half in shadow, above the grey surface of the Moon. It is widely credited with changing how people pictured their own planet, small, whole and shared, and with feeding the energy that led to the first Earth Day in 1970.

That effect was never measured, and it would be hard to measure. It is credited, and the credit has held for more than fifty years, which says a good deal about how many people felt it. One photograph gave millions of people the same picture of home at the same moment.

A pair of eyes above an honesty box

In 2006 Melissa Bateson, Daniel Nettle and Gilbert Roberts ran a small experiment in a staff kitchen at Newcastle University. Tea and coffee were paid for through an honesty box, with a price list pinned above it. Each week the small image at the top of the list changed, alternating between pictures of flowers and pictures of a pair of eyes. In the weeks with eyes, people paid nearly three times as much for their drinks.

Later studies of watching eyes have had mixed results, some finding the effect and others finding very little, so it remains an open and interesting question. The original still shows how lightly an image can touch behaviour: a small picture, barely looked at, and a kitchen full of people quietly more careful to pay their way.

Half seen

Images that are only half seen have a lively history of their own. In 1957 the market researcher James Vicary announced that flashing the words "Eat popcorn" and "Drink Coca-Cola" on a cinema screen, too fast for anyone to notice, had lifted sales at the counter. The claim travelled around the world. In 1962 Vicary himself described the original study as a gimmick, with too little data to mean anything.

The careful research that followed tells a subtler story. In 2006 Johan Karremans, Wolfgang Stroebe and Jasper Claus flashed the name of an iced tea brand too briefly to be consciously seen, then offered people a drink. The hidden name shifted their choice, and only among people who were already thirsty. A hidden cue seems able to nudge something already present in a person, rather than create a wish from nothing. Priming research more widely has a mixed record when studies are repeated, which is worth remembering whenever an image is said to work on us unseen.

A hidden cue seems able to nudge something already present in a person, rather than create a wish from nothing.

The care images ask of us

Put side by side, these studies say something gentle and useful. Images do their work quietly. They reach us fully seen and half seen, on hospital walls, on screens and in kitchens, and they tend to strengthen what is already present in the person looking. That gives anyone who makes images, and anyone who puts them into the world, a small and real responsibility.

At Intention we try to meet it in simple ways. We choose images that leave people a little calmer and a little more awake to what is around them. ClaraXenia's Photo Art is expressive, intuitive and curious photography: an older woman crossing a street in Budapest in All Star shoes worn just enough, two palm trees against the Barcelona sun with soap bubbles drifting up through the light. The photograph always comes first, and the Word of Intention arrives afterwards, out of what the image already holds. The Word is named openly, on the piece and on its page, so whoever wears it or hangs it on a wall knows exactly what they are keeping close. Everything we place in an image is there to be seen.

Old Star, a photograph by ClaraXenia of an older woman in All Star shoes on a Budapest street, framed in wood on a living room wall
Old Star, photographed by ClaraXenia in Budapest. Paired with the Word Respect.

The images we live with

Most of the images in a day pass in a second or two. A few stay: the one on the bedroom wall, the one on the front of a favourite hoodie, the one we pause over without quite knowing why. Those are the images with time to do their slow work, in the way the trees outside Ulrich's windows did. In Where Your Attention Goes we wrote about how attention shapes what we notice, and the pictures we live with are among the places attention returns to most often. Choosing them usually happens in a moment, in a shop or while scrolling, and living with them can go on for years.

Hat On, a photograph by ClaraXenia, in a black frame on a wall
Hat On, photographed by ClaraXenia. Paired with the Word Freedom, a moment suspended just before the yes.

Sources

  • Ulrich, R. S. (1984). View through a window may influence recovery from surgery. Science, 224, 420 to 421.
  • Anders, W. (1968). Earthrise, Apollo 8, NASA.
  • Bateson, M., Nettle, D. and Roberts, G. (2006). Cues of being watched enhance cooperation in a real-world setting. Biology Letters, 2, 412 to 414.
  • Karremans, J. C., Stroebe, W. and Claus, J. (2006). Beyond Vicary's fantasies: The impact of subliminal priming and brand choice. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 42, 792 to 798.

A quiet extension of this idea

Our pieces are built around this principle. A single word, placed so it naturally comes back into your attention during the day. Not something you have to focus on the whole day, just something that stays with you.

Explore the words

← Older Post Newer Post →

Leave a comment

Between States

RSS
Framed Word of Intention print Synergy in a black frame in a home interior

Christmas Gifts for Colleagues and Teams

By Nils Lundvang

Coworker and employee Christmas gift ideas, from a small gift for the person at the next desk to pieces for a whole team carrying your...

Read more
Framed Word of Intention print Love in a wood frame in a home interior

Christmas Gifts for Her, Chosen for Her Days

By Nils Lundvang

Christmas gift ideas for her, whether she is a partner, a mother, a sister or a close friend: what research says about gifts that are...

Read more

Questions

What this raises

Can looking at nature help people recover?

One well known study suggests it can help. In 1984 Roger Ulrich reported in Science that surgery patients whose window looked onto trees went home sooner and needed fewer strong painkillers than matched patients facing a brick wall. It was a small study in one hospital, and it has shaped hospital design ever since.

Do subliminal messages work?

Only in a limited way. The famous 1957 cinema claim about hidden popcorn and cola messages was later described by its author as a gimmick. Careful research, such as Karremans and colleagues in 2006, found that a hidden brand name could shift choice only for people who were already thirsty. Hidden cues seem to nudge what is already there rather than create new wants, and priming studies have a mixed record when repeated.

Why is the Earthrise photograph so important?

Bill Anders took Earthrise on 24 December 1968 during Apollo 8, showing the Earth rising over the Moon. It is widely credited with changing how people pictured their planet and with feeding the energy behind the first Earth Day in 1970. That influence is credited rather than measured.

What is the watching eyes effect?

In 2006 Bateson, Nettle and Roberts placed a small image above an honesty box in a university kitchen, alternating eyes and flowers each week. In the weeks with eyes, people paid nearly three times as much for their drinks. Later studies have had mixed results, so it remains an open question.

What kind of photography is Intention's Photo Art?

Photo Art is expressive, intuitive and curious photography by ClaraXenia, co-founder of Intention. Each photograph comes first, and a Word of Intention is chosen afterwards from what the image holds. You can wear the pairing on apparel or hang it on a wall.

Join the community of great intentions

@intentioncph